I HAVE a clear image in my head of the moment that Sonny Carey spent €105,000 of Tony Kilduff’s money at the Goffs Arkle Sale in 2024. He was standing with his wife Mary, the Goffs bloodstock director, and if spending that amount on behalf of a client is pressure, then it doubles when the client is a relation. Tony Kilduff is Mary’s uncle.
For that amount of money they took ownership of a bay filly by No Risk At All (My Risk), bred by Whitley Stud and sold through Sally Aston’s Goldford Stud. Whitley Stud is the breeding entity of Dominic Burke.
I do enjoy looking back at what the purchaser said at the sales, and how prescient they were in the post-buying comments. This is what Sonny Carey had to say, his words of wisdom.
“The plan is to get her home, break her and tip away with her, and see how she goes. She is a beautiful filly, the full package. Hopefully, she will be lucky now. She is for a client but will come back to us. Hopefully, she is a long-term broodmare. She was the one we wanted, and I’m delighted to get her.”
Tony Kilduff
After the weekend, not only has Brosna Shine, as she is named, become a smart racing and broodmare prospect, but is worth more than what Tony Kilduff paid for her.
She is twice a winner in four starts; the weekend win gained in the Listed Coolmore NH Sires Hurricane Lane Irish EBF Mares INH Flat Race – now that is a mouthful! On her debut at Punchestown Brosna Shine was third in the €100,000 Goffs Defender Bumper, followed by an impressive win last December in Fairyhouse. She did well on her only other start in a Grade 2 bumper but was sick afterwards and rested for the summer. Next stop is a maiden hurdle, and she is clearly a mare with a bright future.
Brosna Shine is one of three winners out of seven-time track winner Baby Shine (King’s Theatre) who placed in listed bumpers, hurdle races and chases when trained by Lucy Wadham. She also won a point-to-point for her breeder Kevin O’Donnell. She is the fifth foal out of Baby Shine. The first did not race, the second was the Alan King-trained Baby Sage (Flemensfirth) who won a bumper and a hurdle race, and the third is Windsurfer (Getaway).
A €65,000 foal buy by Lady Jane Grosvenor, he didn’t sell as a store but is a dual hurdle winner for Ben Case.
Goldford Stud
Alan King also saddled Baby Shine’s next, the once-raced Baby Thyme (No Risk At All), a full-sister to the weekend listed winner.
What a shame that she did not get to build on the promise of that single outing, as she was third to La Zoubida – a dual hurdle winner since – in a bumper, beaten just over two lengths.
The weekend win for Brosna Shine could not have been better timed, as Baby Sage is Lot 866 in the Goffs December National Hunt Sale from Goldford Stud. Better still, she is carrying her first foal by No Risk At All!
This is a female family that every generation produces a good horse. Baby Shine’s half-sister Coolgreaney (Bob Back) was twice successful in Grade 3 chases, at Punchestown and Naas.
Two generations back is Belvederian (Deep Run), the Grade 2 Morris Oil Chase winner who sported the black and white hooped colours of Sir Anthony O’Reilly.
Elegantemente’s Cheltenham win offers more
BROSNA Shine’s listed bumper triumph came 23 and a half hours after anther daughter of No Risk At All was victorious in a listed bumper at Cheltenham.
This was the Robcour-owned Elegantemente, trained by Henry de Bromhead, and the four-year-old accounted for another Irish-trained runner, Eastern Whisper, who is trained by Sonny Carey. What a pair of talented youngsters Carey has for this season.
After she won a mares’ bumper at Ballinrobe in August, Elegantemente was set to run in a listed bumper last month at Gowran Park but was found to be coughing and withdrawn. The race was won by Sarah’s Lawn who was a length behind Brosna Shine at Navan. There is no doubt that we will all have to learn to pronounce Elegantemente because she is a filly with huge prospects, and the race she won at Cheltenham has an honourable roll of honour.
Elegantly
Elegantemente is the Italian for elegantly, and she was bred by Olivier Tricot at his Haras de la Vallée in Normandy. He sold her as a two-year-old to Robcour’s Allez Farms for €90,000 at Arqana. She is the second blacktype winner for Si St Eloi (Limnos) who placed five times in France but failed to win. She is dam of a listed Auteuil chase winner, Kapeloi (Kapgarde).
This is a female line that has no shortage of blacktype, and one of the best-known winners appears under Elegantemente’s third dam. This is Balko (Pistolet Bleu), the Grade 2 hurdle and chase winner who became a good sire. An even better runner was Oculi (Denham Red), and he was a two-time Grade 1 chase winner at Auteuil.
Haras de Montaigu
A 10% rise in his stud fee to €22,000 this year was no deterrent to breeders using No Risk At All who has been at Haras de Montaigu since he went to stud in 2013. He started out on the road to becoming one of France’s premier sires at a fee of just €2,500.
With his winners last weekend his tally of blacktype winners has edged closer to a benchmark number, and now stands at 47, with 90 who have earned some form of blacktype.
No Risk At All’s very first crop included his most prolific Grade 1 winner Epatante. She won the Champion Hurdle, Aintree Hurdle, two editions of the Christmas Hurdle, and another two Fighting Fifth Hurdles.
This year Epatante foaled her third colt in quick succession by Walk In The Park. What a first crop that was for No Risk At All, as another of its members was Allaho, twice winner of the Grade 1 Ryanair Chase at Cheltenham, while also winning on two occasions at the same level in Punchestown. There were seven other blacktype winners in that initial crop.
Cheltenham record
Were No Risk At All to have an increase in fee again this year it would come as no surprise.
In recent days, his son Hero Of Demacia set a Tattersalls Cheltenham record when selling to Gordon Elliott and Aidan O’Ryan for £560,000.
A month or so earlier Oehlen (No Risk At All), an Auteuil debut-winning three-year-old, cost €500,000 at Arqana and now joins Willie Mullins.
In April, the three-year-old No Risk Allen sold through Aktem for €475,000.
Meanwhile, among stores by No Risk At All this year, we saw prices such as €370,000 at the Derby Sale (Joe Tizzard), €240,000 (Gordon Elliott) and €200,000 (Willie Mullins) at Goffs.
It is a surprise to learn that No Risk At All has not been champion sire in France, though often in the top three. Then again, all his best runners have been successful outside France where he has not had a Grade 1 winner, and just two at Grade 2 level.