THE three Olympic equestrian affiliates and Para Equestrian Ireland say the examinership of Horse Sport Ireland (HSI) must lead to meaningful reform, proper accountability and a sustainable future for the €1 billion industry as it reaches its final week ahead of a return date to the High Court on November 30th.
Following the announcement that HSI was entering examinership back in August, a meeting of the equestrian affiliates was convened to consider the implications for the wider industry. Following that meeting, a letter signed by 10 equestrian affiliates was sent to the Ministers for Agriculture and Sport, outlining concerns about the crisis and calling for specific changes to HSI’s Constitution, Board and senior management.
The three Olympic affiliates - Showjumping Ireland, Eventing Ireland and Dressage Ireland - and Para Equestrian Ireland then agreed to establish a single representative group, the Irish Equestrian Sports Alliance (IESA), to provide a unified voice in discussions with Government and other parties. It is understood the IESA was one of the three bidders forward to the examiner as potential investors to financially aid Horse Sport Ireland.
In a statement to The Irish Field, the IESA said: “The examinership of HSI has created a grave and uncertain situation for Irish equestrian sport. Creditors face uncertainty about the recovery of monies owed to them, legal proceedings remain unresolved, and organisations across the industry are concerned about the consequences for their members and their future activities.
“IESA is closely monitoring developments. Its primary responsibility is to protect the interests of its members and the wider equestrian community. Those involved in the sport should not be expected to carry the financial consequences of decisions and failures for which they were not responsible. IESA has supported the appointment of the Examiner and his efforts to secure a successful outcome through the statutory examinership process.
“However, the search for investors and the consideration of proposals involving HSI’s assets raise important questions about the future structure, independence and financial sustainability of the International Federation.
“IESA has made its position clear to Government including that:
The Alliance went on to say: “HSI is a company limited by guarantee and performs important national functions, supported substantially through public funding and public contracts. Those arrangements carry responsibilities. Public funding and public contracts must support an organisation that is financially sustainable, properly governed and capable of delivering the services expected of it. They cannot simply be used to sustain an existing structure without addressing the underlying problems.
“The present crisis did not arise overnight. Concerns about HSI’s governance, financial management, leadership and relationships with its affiliates have been raised repeatedly over a number of years. These concerns have been reflected in parliamentary discussions and extensive reporting in the national and equestrian press.”
Contingency planning
The statement added: “IESA recognises that the Examiner must complete his work and that the Court will ultimately consider the proposals put before it. We will respect that process. However, it would be irresponsible for the industry and Government to assume that the continuation of the existing company, in its current or restructured form, is necessarily the best or only solution.
“If the examinership cannot deliver a genuinely independent, financially sustainable and properly governed national federation, then alternative arrangements must be considered. In that context, liquidation may have to be examined as a possible outcome, however undesirable, if it is ultimately the route to ending the present situation and establishing a properly managed and sustainable structure for the future.
“This is not a position that IESA takes lightly. It is a recognition that preserving the existing corporate structure must not take precedence over protecting the long-term interests of Irish equestrian sport.
“IESA has requested meetings with Government to ensure that contingency planning takes place and that the interests of the industry are protected whatever the outcome of the examinership. The objective of IESA is not to create further conflict or to undermine the work of the Examiner. It is to ensure that the crisis becomes an opportunity for meaningful and lasting reform.
“Irish equestrian sport needs an international federation that is financially responsible, transparent, accountable and representative of the organisations and people it serves. It must have the confidence of its affiliates, athletes, breeders, owners, organisers, volunteers and Government. The four Olympic affiliates remain willing to work constructively with Government, the Examiner and all relevant stakeholders to achieve that outcome. The priority must be the future of Irish equestrian sport and the development of a €1 billion industry, not simply the survival of the existing corporate structure,” it concluded.