After Henry de Bromhead withdrew The Big Westerner on account of the good-to-yielding ground, Willie Mullins was guaranteed a record-extending 12th John Durkan Chase with one of his nine runners, and despite a one-dimensional aspect to the field, Sunday’s Grade 1 at Punchestown proved an exciting watch.
Every single horse remained in contention three out, with a faster pace turning for home whittling down the leading contenders to five, including the 2025 and 2024 victors Gaelic Warrior (10/11f) and Fact To File (3/1).
Longtime leader Kitzbuhel and Dan King outran odds of 10/1 until the final fence, where Final Demand (8/1), under Patrick Mullins, and Fact To File, under Harry Cobden, leapt into the lead. J.P. McManus’ nine-year-old briefly edged ahead on the run-in, but Final Demand found hidden reserves to battle back and lead by a neck on the line.
Gaelic Warrior finished another three and three-quarter lengths further back in third, just half a length in front of Kitzbuhel. All nine horses finished the two-and-a-half-mile Grade 1.
“It was a fantastic race,” Willie Mullins reflected. “Very few of my horses were disappointing; they all ran well enough. What a result for the Mullins family, not just Closutton. To see Patrick win a Grade 1 and dare I say, outriding Harry Cobden from the last!
“Patrick said he thought he had the race won and he just missed the last, and he had to go at it a second time, so it just shows how much this horse has improved from last year.”
Graduation day
Sunday undoubtedly marked a career-best performance from Final Demand, given his relative inexperience against older rivals. A dual Grade 1 winner over hurdles, Bryan Drew and Professor Caroline Tisdall’s bay made it two from two over fences last Christmas when winning the Grade 1 Faugheen Novice Chase at Limerick, but later disappointed at the Dublin Racing Festival and was recently disqualified from his runner-up effort in the Brown Advisory Novices’ Chase.
On his Punchestown performance, the winning trainer commented: “First day of big school, in against those top-class horses, he was good the whole way around, jumping immaculately Patrick said. I was amazed by the turn of foot he showed from the last home, he just got down and ground it out. For a second season novice, that’s a huge result.”
Reflecting on beaten horses, Mullins said of Gaelic Warrior: “He probably took a blow that we weren’t expecting him to take, but you never know until you get to the races.
“I loved the way Kitzbuhel ran. Nick Rockett ran well while needing the run. Impaire Et Passe probably disappointed me; I thought on his homework he would run a lot better, so he’s going to improve. I’d say Kaid d’Authie ran a cracker; his homework had been very good and he brought that to the track, but he needed the run as well.”
In the aftermath, Patrick Mullins shared his hopes of keeping the ride on Final Demand, as he believes the son of Walk In The Park could win the Cheltenham Gold Cup.
On why he rates the seven-year-old over last year’s fancy Gaelic Warrior, the rider explained: “I don’t necessarily think he’s going to beat Gaelic Warrior, but to me, he’s a Gold Cup horse to look at him – his physique, the way he settles, the way he jumps and the further, the better; I think he’s a really strong stayer.
“Now whether he can beat Gaelic Warrior is another point but if you can get him there on the day, anything can happen. From the first day I sat on him, I thought he’s that type of horse.”