A HEATED debate between TDs on the greyhound racing industry this week failed to stop the Government getting next year’s funding for both horse and greyhound racing approved by a large majority in Dáil Éireann.

Since the formation of Horse Racing Ireland in 2001, Government funding for horseracing has been linked to greyhound racing’s funding in a 80:20 ratio. The grant was initially influenced by betting tax receipts but since 2009 it has been a Budget decision and the money comes from central funding. Responsibility has resided with the Department of Agriculture since 2010.

The Department’s allocation to the Horse & Greyhound Racing Fund for 2027 is €102 million, with €81.6 million going to horseracing and €20.4 million allocated to greyhound racing.

When the Minister for Agriculture Martin Heydon asked the Dáil to approve this funding earlier in the week, he faced strong opposition from Labour, Social Democrat and People Before Profit TDs, who were mainly questioning the viability of the greyhound racing sector, following a recent report from the Houses of the Oireachtas Parliamentary Budget Office which raised questions about the level of State support it receives.

Sinn Féin TD Martin Kenny, while expressing his party’s support for the motion, said his party “would like to see the funding include the wider horse sport industry because it is not just those in the thoroughbred sector who need support. Other sectors, which are much larger and have an awful lot more people involved in them, need to be properly funded and looked after.”

Prize money

Turning his attention to prize money, he said: “We see the wealthiest people in the country usually picking up these prize funds. That does not sit well with the general public. We need to look at how this whole industry works and is developed because, for many people out there, it is an elitist group of people who are involved in it. We need to recognise that.

“The Minister is shaking his head, but that is how the people I represent see it. Maybe the Minister does not see it like that in Kildare but, certainly, that is how we see it where we are. We need to recognise that having a large volume of State money and public funds going into an industry is something that needs deep and continued scrutiny.”

Another Sinn Féin TD, Shónagh Ní Raghallaigh, suggested that funding for greyhound racing should be decoupled from horseracing revenue “until further evidence of the greyhound industry’s economic viability is produced”.

Pony racing

Deputy Michael Cahill, a Fianna Fáil TD for Kerry, asked that €150,000 of the €81.6 million earmarked for horseracing be given to the pony racing sector.

“HRI has in the past raised concerns around governance, accountability, safeguarding, welfare and regulation in respect of horse and pony racing,” he said. “The [Irish] Horse and Pony Racing Association is willing and able to work within the appropriate remit and meet the standards required. In view of the massive funding the Government and taxpayer have allocated, I call on Horse Racing Ireland to engage with the IHPRA.

“This request is straightforward. I ask for Horse Racing Ireland to reopen engagement with the IHPRA, meet with it and give it an opportunity to demonstrate it can meet the required standards. This is in the interests of this great sport and, more importantly, the health and safety of all involved.”

Peter ‘Chap’ Cleere, Fianna Fáil TD for Kilkenny, said: “I have had an awful lot of trainers and owners on to me from both codes who are worried sick about their future because when they hear the likes of Social Democrats, People Before Profit and the Green Party talking about banning greyhound racing, they know where it will go. It will start off with greyhound racing and then go to horse racing.”

The motion was carried by 136 votes to 24. The sole Green Party TD also voted against the motion, as did one Independent TD and one Sinn Féin TD, despite Sinn Féin’s stated support for the motion.