IT was both an unfortunate and unsatisfactory episode last weekend that saw the ineligibility of two intended runners in Navan’s listed mares’ bumper go virtually without communication to the relevant trainers until only the night before the race.
According to the connections involved, the trainers were contacted by the authorities around 6pm on Saturday night - nearly a full day and a half after declarations had been made for the blacktype event.
The origin of the issue comes from changes introduced last season whereby horses who have run in more than six races, and/or have run in a hurdle race, are to be excluded from graded and listed bumpers.
Horse Racing Ireland noted that the two runners’ ineligibility wasn’t picked up on in standard entry and declaration checks. Lessons will surely have been learned with regard to the systems in place since then to avoid a repeat.
However frustrating that might have been for those involved, what was similarly grating for punters and racegoers was how long it took for the two horses to be withdrawn officially. The issue had reportedly been flagged to both trainers on Saturday night around 6pm, and the issue was being spoken about online from before 7pm, when the part-owners of one runner alerted the media to the matter.
Disappointingly, one of the trainers involved said they contacted the authorities at around 10.45am on Sunday morning to query why their mare was still left in the field as a runner - despite being told the night before she was not allowed to take part. Remember, racing kicked off in under an hour’s time at 11.40am.
The Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board’s raceday account on X (Twitter) posted the day’s non-runners for Navan at 10.39am, and neither mare featured as being a withdrawal in that post. It wasn’t until 11.05am - nearly 30 mins before the opener - that a notice on the same account signalled the mares were out due to not being qualified.
Information delay
The solution seems pretty simple in a case like this. As soon as the ineligibility was identified by the authorities, both mares should have been automatically withdrawn from the listed bumper on the spot. Done and dusted.
Instead, there were roughly 17 hours between when the issue was communicated to the trainers and when the mares were taken out officially. That is a slack look on any day of the week, let alone a blacktype race on a prominent festival weekend.
There are knock-on implications for the betting market when likely, soon-to-be-announced or known non runners (like these mares) remain in a race for longer than needed. It leaves obvious scope for market manipulation.
The obvious route for doing so is bookmakers shortening the odds of a horse they anticipate is unlikely to run, therefore creating a greater Rule 4 deduction to existing bets in the race.
Whether layers own up to it or not, it’s far from an unusual occurrence to see market moves like this.
Even recently, a suspected example popped up in Ireland, where a horse who was well beaten the day before was ‘backed’ from 7/2 into 7/4 on the morning of the race. It certainly wouldn’t have been the horse’s unplaced performance the night before that triggered such a move, so where would that supposed market confidence have come from? In this particular case, the same horse did actually take his chance - genuine connections wanted to run on back-to-back days - and he was eased out to 11/4 and 5/2 closer to the off.
The same runner ended up soundly enough beaten, but one would have to wonder about the origins of the early market move. There are considerably more of these episodes where the horses do not run and are taken out - and those cases hit punters in the pocket.
As for last weekend at Navan, delaying the time from which it became apparent that the two bumper runners wouldn’t line up meant there was a clear window where someone could have attempted to manipulate the market and cause an inflated Rule 4. It was a totally avoidable 17-hour gap where punters could also have put their money down on two mares who were essentially never going to run.
If it is a case that the current rules dictate such a withdrawal needs to be conducted with the power of the stewards on raceday, that is an outdated situation. As soon as a horse is deemed ineligible, that needs to be acted on immediately for all parties concerned.
PLENTY has been made of Willie Mullins’ comments on the quickness of the ground at last year’s Cheltenham Festival in recent days, but he’s far from the only leading Irish trainer to have expressed similar sentiments.
In case you missed it, the meeting’s most successful trainer told members of the press last week: “There was a lot of damage done the last two days in Cheltenham last year because they hadn’t watered properly… J.P. [McManus] took out Fact To File [from the Ryanair Chase], and we had significant damage from the Thursday and the Friday with some of our runners, which is not on. It needs to be checked and looked at, whether it’s the clerk of the course or the manager or whoever does it.”
Remember, though, in the aftermath of the meeting, Gordon Elliott also expressed concerns when speaking to the Nick Luck Daily Podcast.
“A lot of our novices came home a bit sore, a bit shoulder-y. Our bumpers horses too. For me, that’s the one concern,” Elliott noted. “I’m not saying ground is too good or too bad [from a racing preference perspective] - everyone has got to make their own decisions on what they like - but, for me, no horse should come home from Cheltenham sore.
“It was definitely more the case this year than other years. I don’t think we’ve ever had a problem before. This year, we definitely had five or six horses come home a bit shoulder-y, but they’ll be okay.”
The latest high-profile voice to shed light on the argument was Gavin Cromwell, speaking as part of this week’s Big Interview in The Irish Field.
“I was a bit disappointed,” Cromwell said. “You’d like to see more kindness in the ground. We had horses come out of it who were sore. I don’t know if many would have complained if we were racing on the softer side.”
Regardless of where you stand on what the optimum going at Cheltenham should look like, when three men with a combined total of 172 Festival winners are reporting a number of their horses to be sore in the aftermath, something surely has to change promptly.
A fascinating lead-up to this season’s spring spectacular awaits.