THE November Meeting at Cheltenham was blighted by ground issues that lead to 53 non-runners over the three days. The lack of rain this summer and autumn has been a persistent problem for the industry, but we do not help ourselves with inaccurate going descriptions.

It is correctly and persistently stated that the job of a clerk of the course is a thankless one, but it is a job with a high degree of responsibility that requires a flexible approach, and flexibility means embracing all the tools at your disposure to ensure accuracy.

The most important tool that a clerk can use are the race times. Jockeys’ opinions are interesting and help paint a picture of how the ground is riding, but this is a professional sport that must embrace accuracy, not just opinions.

Let’s look at the times on the three days of the meeting and make a simple comparison with the Racing Post standard times to create an accurate picture of the ground. I can understand that the ground could be different to the description before a race has been run, but once the action begins a clerk must be proactive and react to the times.

If races are evenly-run, times can be relied upon as being an accurate guide and for that reason they should take into consideration the finishing speed percentages (FSP).

Day 1 official going description: Good (Good to Soft in places)

1. Norman Fletcher: 5m 04.51s (+0.51s) FSP: 103.75% - Evenly Run

2. D Art D art: 6m 19.64s: (+2.64s) FSP: 108.25% - Steady Pace

3. Jonbon: 3m49.18s: (-2.82s) FSP: 102.55% - Evenly Run

4. Thunder Rock: 5m 01.30s (-0.30s) FSP: 106.82% - Steady Pace

5. Lock Stock: 5m 02.01s (-1.99s) FSP: 102.51% - Evenly Run

6. Lexington Wood: 3m 52.67s (+2.67s) FSP: 107.00% - Steady Pace

On Friday both Jonbon and Lock Stock produced final times that were a good deal faster than standard and in evenly run contests. The ground was much faster than described with good to firm being a more accurate call. This was backed up by Sean Bowen, who called the ground good to firm, and David Pipe who described it as ‘quite quick’.

The official description could have been changed after the first race and should have been changed to good to firm after Jonbon managed to dictate an even gallop in the Shloer Chase ands dip 2.82s under standard.

Overnight temperatures between the first two days dipped to -4C, preventing any watering which is completely out of the control of the executive. As a result, the ground was changed to Good (Good to Firm in places) overnight. Now let’s look at what happened on Saturday.

Day 2 official going description: Good (Good to Firm in places)

1. Dinoland: 6m 29.37s (+12.37s) FSP: 113.86% Slowly Run

2. Atomic City: 3m 54.80s (+4.80s) FSP: 106.66% Steadily Run

3. Passing Diamond: 3m 53,34s (+1.34s) FSP: 101.98% Evenly Run

4. Meetmebythesea: 4m 52.36s (-8.64s) FSP: 106.61% Steadily Run

5. Black Bamboo: 5m 50.22s (+2.22s) FSP: 102.69% Evenly Run

6. Sunny South West: 5m 05.16s (+1.16s) FSP: 107.41% Steadily Run

7. Elegantemente: 3m 53.74s (+7.74s) FSP: 109.78% Steadily Run

This was a mixed bag in terms of how races were run, with Meetmebythesea winning the Paddy Power Gold Cup in a time 8.64s faster than standard, indicating he was a graded chaser in a handicap. It also is a strong indicator of the ground being good to firm. I would add that such a fast time would not have been achieved if there had been a lot of jar in the ground, preventing horses from letting themselves down properly, but it was certainly indicative of good to firm ground.

The rain arrived for the third day of the meeting with 15mm hitting the track, which led to standing water and an inspection. But when racing got underway, the ground was unchanged, described as being Good (Good to Firm in places) suggesting the rain had no effect. This was changed to good after the third race.

Day 3 official going description: Good (Good to Firm in places) changed to Good after third race

1. Get Out of My Way: 4m03.25s (+13.25s) FSP: 106.13% Steadily Run

2. Sony Bill: 5m04.11s (+3.11s) FSP: 101.71% Evenly Run

3. Authoceltic: 4m01.58s (+9.58s) FSP: 104.06% Steadily run

4. Holokea: 7m 17.30s (+16.30s) FSP: 105.39% Steadily Run

5. Pioneer Pete: 4m 00.56s (+10.56s): 103.61% Evenly Run

6. Dundee Law: 3m 56.37s (+10.37s): 104.50% Steadily Run

The rain had a significant effect on the ground, according to the times, and changing the description after three races was the correct call. According to the times, the ground was easier at the start of the meeting than on the previous day which is logical given the rain that had fallen and it should have been described as good. The Sony Bill time, in an evenly run, contest is the best indicator of the ground being good. Thereafter there was a deterioration in the conditions which became good to soft, as indicated by the Pioneer Pete time which was 10.56s above standard in an evenly-run contest. We should be using times as sole indicator of ground conditions. Jockeys’ opinions are valid but must come secondary to the facts.

McManus runners the standouts

THERE were two standout performances at the meeting. Jonbon bounced off the fast ground under a beautifully judged ride by Harry Cobden, rating him perfectly in the lead throughout and getting him to jump as well as he can.

His finishing speed percentage of 102.55% shows just how well judged a ride this was, and Jonbon’s Race iQ Jump Index of 7.0 out of 10 whilst not outstanding is in accordance with his lifetime score of 7.1.

This was the simplest task that he had faced for some time, but he made no mistake and seemed to enjoy making the running and bouncing off the fast ground.

The Tingle Creek could cut up into a small field affair and if so, similar tactics will make him very competitive.

Destined for more

Meetmebythesea in the Paddy Power Gold Cup handicap chase was an outstanding performance from a horse destined for much better with a tilt at the King George not out of the question.

He jumped superbly with the best round of jumping since he went chasing, garnering a Race iQ Time Index of 8.7 out of 10, and in being so efficient he gained 6.14 lengths on his rivals.

Whilst his jumping stood out, the way he stormed up the hill was equally impressive.

He produced a very strong final furlong of 14.65s which saw him hit the line strongly and this was 0.48s faster than Blueking D’Oroux who was not stopping in second place.

Meetmebythesea has improved considerably since being stepped up in trip on his last two starts and there is still three miles to explore with him.

Whilst he lacks the experience for a King George it is a race that we will surely see him in one day whether it be this season or next.

There is one common denominator that draws Jonbon and Meetmebythesea and that is the brilliance of Harry Cobden, which was publicly acknowledged by J.P. McManus over the weekend.